GAR vs NAR in Indonesian Coal: Complete Technical Guide for International Coal Buyers

IEC | INDONESIA EXPORT CENTER

UNDERSTANDING COAL CALORIFIC VALUE

GAR | NAR | Moisture | Analytical Basis | Coal Procurement Specifications

GAR vs NAR: Why the Difference Matters

International coal importers frequently encounter two important calorific-value terms when evaluating Indonesian thermal coal: GAR (Gross As Received) and NAR (Net As Received).

Understanding the difference between GAR and NAR is essential for comparing coal offers, evaluating fuel costs, and preparing accurate procurement specifications.

A supplier quotation that identifies only a heating-value number without its analytical basis may lead to misunderstandings and commercial disputes.

Indonesia Export Center (IEC) facilitates coal sourcing inquiries and encourages buyers to use complete, measurable technical specifications.

What Is GAR?

GAR stands for Gross As Received.

It refers to gross calorific value measured or expressed for coal in its as-received condition.

The value includes the heat associated with condensation of water vapor in the gross calorific-value determination.

Because the as-received condition includes moisture, total moisture is relevant to the reported GAR value.

What Is NAR?

NAR stands for Net As Received.

It represents net calorific value for coal in its as-received condition.

Net calorific value accounts for the energy associated with water remaining as vapor, including water related to the coal’s moisture and hydrogen content.

NAR is therefore generally lower than GAR for the same coal sample on the same as-received basis.

GAR vs NAR Comparison Table

Characteristic GAR NAR
Full Name Gross As Received Net As Received
Heating-Value Type Gross Net
Moisture Basis As Received As Received
Treatment of Water Vapor Includes condensation heat Excludes condensation heat
Typical Relative Value Higher Lower
Common Use Coal specification and trading Fuel energy and procurement analysis
Interchangeable? No No

Why GAR and NAR Are Different

The difference arises primarily from how the heating-value calculation treats water associated with the coal.

Coal contains moisture, and combustion of hydrogen in coal also produces water.

Gross calorific value includes the heat that would be recovered if the resulting water vapor were condensed under the specified reference conditions.

Net calorific value does not include that condensation heat.

The exact difference depends on the coal’s composition, moisture, and the calculation standard.

Is There a Fixed Conversion from GAR to NAR?

No universal fixed conversion factor is appropriate for all coal.

A technically defensible conversion requires the relevant analytical data and an applicable standard.

Buyers should avoid relying on a generic deduction or percentage without understanding its assumptions.

Coal Calorific-Value Reporting Bases

Coal heating values may be reported using several different bases.

As Received (AR)

Represents the coal with moisture in its as-received condition.

Air Dried Basis (ADB)

Represents the coal after conditioning under defined air-drying procedures.

Dry Basis (DB)

Represents results calculated with moisture excluded.

Dry Ash Free Basis (DAF)

Represents a basis excluding moisture and ash.

These bases are not interchangeable.

Why Moisture Matters

Moisture affects the mass and heating value of the delivered fuel.

Two coal samples with similar dry-basis calorific values may have different as-received values because of different moisture contents.

This is one reason buyers should request total moisture data alongside GAR or NAR.

Example: Comparing Coal Offers

Consider two hypothetical coal offers:

Parameter Offer A Offer B
Quoted Heating Value 4,200 kcal/kg 4,200 kcal/kg
Reporting Basis GAR NAR
Total Moisture Not provided Not provided
Ash Not provided Not provided
Sulfur Not provided Not provided

These offers cannot be treated as technically equivalent.

Offer A quotes gross as-received calorific value, while Offer B quotes net as-received calorific value.

Additional laboratory data would be required for a meaningful comparison.

GAR and Coal Pricing

Coal prices are sometimes discussed in relation to calorific-value categories.

However, a quotation based on GAR should not be compared directly with a quotation based on NAR without adjusting for the technical differences.

Commercial comparison also requires consideration of ash, sulfur, moisture, quantity, delivery terms, and other costs.

Understanding Total Moisture and Inherent Moisture

Total Moisture (TM) and Inherent Moisture (IM) are different coal-analysis parameters.

Total moisture reflects the moisture measured according to the applicable test procedure for the coal sample.

Inherent moisture relates to moisture retained under defined analytical conditions.

The values should not be substituted for one another.

GAR and NAR in a Certificate of Analysis

A complete coal COA should identify the reported calorific-value basis and analytical method.

COA Field Buyer Verification
Sample ID Traceable identification
Sampling Date Recorded
Laboratory Identified
GAR Value and unit
NAR Value where reported
Total Moisture Measured result
Inherent Moisture Measured result
Hydrogen Where needed for calculation
Ash Measured result
Sulfur Measured result
Analytical Standard Identified
Coal Source Documented where available

How Buyers Should Write a Coal Specification

Instead of requesting:

“Coal 4200”

Use a complete specification such as:

Product: Thermal Coal
Calorific Value: GAR 4,200 kcal/kg, with agreed contractual tolerance
Total Moisture: [Maximum %] Ash: [Maximum %] Total Sulfur: [Maximum %] Particle Size: [Required Range] Sampling and Testing: [Agreed Standard] Quantity: [MT] Delivery Term: [Incoterm and Named Port]

The numerical GAR in this example is an illustrative buyer requirement, not a claim of available stock.

Coal Quality Disputes

Disputes may arise when the buyer and seller use different analytical bases, sampling procedures, or laboratories.

A coal sales contract should define:

  1. Required calorific-value basis.
  2. Accepted testing standards.
  3. Sampling procedures.
  4. Independent surveyor arrangements.
  5. Quality tolerances.
  6. Price adjustments.
  7. Rejection conditions.
  8. Dispute-testing procedures.

Common Procurement Mistakes

Mistake 1: Treating GAR and NAR as Equal

They represent different heating-value measurements.

Mistake 2: Ignoring Moisture

Moisture affects as-received heating value and cargo economics.

Mistake 3: Comparing Different Analytical Bases

ADB, DB, DAF, and AR results should not be compared without appropriate adjustment.

Mistake 4: Using a Generic Conversion Factor

Conversion depends on the coal’s characteristics and the applicable calculation standard.

Mistake 5: Accepting an Unverified COA

A report should be checked for authenticity and relevance to the offered coal.

Mistake 6: Ignoring Other Quality Parameters

Calorific value alone does not establish boiler compatibility.

Frequently Asked Questions

What does GAR mean in coal?

Gross As Received.

What does NAR mean in coal?

Net As Received.

Is NAR normally lower than GAR?

Yes, for the same coal sample and reporting basis.

Can GAR 4200 be treated as NAR 4200?

No.

Can GAR be converted to NAR?

A calculation may be possible using the necessary analytical data and applicable standards.

Does moisture affect GAR?

Yes.

Is GAR the same as ADB?

No. They describe different reporting bases.

Which value should a buyer request?

The buyer should use the basis required by its equipment, contract, and procurement standards.

Can IEC verify the coal’s heating value?

IEC can coordinate requests for supplier documentation, but laboratory verification must be performed by appropriately qualified parties.

Coal Technical Clarification RFQ

Subject: GAR and NAR Clarification – Indonesian Thermal Coal

Dear IEC Team,

We are reviewing Indonesian thermal coal suppliers and require clarification of calorific-value specifications.

Company: [Name] Country: [Country] Required GAR: [Value] Required NAR: [Value, if applicable] Total Moisture Maximum: [Value] Ash Maximum: [Value] Sulfur Maximum: [Value] Quantity: [MT] Destination Port: [Port] Preferred Incoterm: [Term]

Please advise on available supplier COAs, the calorific-value reporting basis, analytical standards, and the procedure for requesting a verified commercial offer.

Best regards,
[Name]

Request Technical Coal Sourcing Information

REQUEST GAR AND NAR TECHNICAL CLARIFICATION

INDONESIA EXPORT CENTER

Connecting Indonesian Products to Global Markets

Website: https://indonesiaexportcenter.com/

WhatsApp: +62 813-3302-277

Related Guides

Indonesian Coal Supplier

Thermal Coal Supplier Indonesia

Coal Procurement from Indonesia

Indonesian Coal Export Supplier Verification

Industry Reference

IEA – Coal Mid-Year Update 2026: Trade

 

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *